Hi there,
What actually happens when you replace a performance evaluation system that was seen as unfair and inaccurate with a new system that is more based on outputs and it is seen as fair and accurate within your company?
Here I want to share a research paper where the researchers collected data from an organization that was changing their performance evaluation system.
Over the period of 14 months of close observation and data collection, researchers have found that an improved performance management system led to higher levels of trust in senior management among employees.
Before we begin, we have to establish some definitions first:
1) Accuracy: Here, it refers to the extent to which employees believe the performance management system is accurate.
2) Instrumentality: Here, it refers to the extent to which employees believe the performance management system is being used appropriately for compensation or promotion decisions.
3) Ability: Here, it refers to the extent to which employees believe the senior management team has the ability to do their job competently.
4) Benevolence: Here, it refers to the extent to which employees believe the senior management team is genuinely concerned about their welfare.
5) Integrity: Here, it refers to the extent to which employees believe the senior management team has a strong sense of justice and fairness.
6) Trust: Here, it refers to the extent to which employees trust the senior management team.
The graph above shows the causal relationship between the improved performance management system and its influence on employees’ perception of senior management.
When companies care about adopting ACCURATE measures, employees notice their senior management’s efforts in trying to be fair which leads to higher levels of trust in the senior management team among employees.
Conversely, if employees think the performance management system is not fair, it means they also think the senior management team is not really concerned about their well-being and welfare.
5 Key Steps in Designing and Developing an Accurate and Fair Performance Management System
1. Use accurate, clear, and objective data
Accurate evaluations help employees understand how their performance is being judged and what specific actions they can take to improve.
By using clear, objective, and measurable criteria, HR managers can ensure that evaluations are fair and consistent across the board.
Transparency in the evaluation process, along with constructive feedback, builds trust and helps employees see the value in the performance management system.
This approach reduces bias and subjectivity, making employees feel that their efforts are fairly recognized and appreciated.
2. Maintain fairness and justice
Fairness and justice are critical for building a Healthy High Performance Culture within a workplace.
HR managers must ensure that all policies are applied consistently across the organization and that performance evaluations are conducted without bias.
Transparent decision-making processes further reinforce this sense of fairness.
When employees see that everyone is treated equally and that decisions are made based on clear, objective criteria, they are more likely to trust the system and feel motivated to perform well.
3. Give feedback to employees on both the process and outcome
When employees perceive a direct correlation between their performance and rewards, such as compensation and promotion, it enhances their motivation and commitment to their work.
HR managers should ensure that performance data is used transparently in these decisions to avoid any feelings of favoritism or unfairness.
Clear communication about how performance metrics influence career advancement and rewards helps employees understand the value of their contributions and motivates them to strive for higher performance levels.
4. Provide training for leaders and managers
Managers play a critical role in the performance management process and determine its effectiveness across the organization.
HR managers should ensure that managers receive proper training to conduct fair and effective evaluations, provide constructive feedback, and handle difficult conversations with empathy and clarity.
This training helps create a more supportive and productive work environment where employees feel guided and valued.
5. Implement a continuous feedback mechanism
Continuous feedback allows employees to adjust their performance and behaviors in real-time, rather than waiting for annual reviews.
HR managers should implement systems that provide regular, constructive feedback, helping employees stay aligned with organizational goals and improve continuously.
This approach fosters a culture of ongoing development and responsiveness, making performance management more dynamic and effective.
Employees benefit from timely insights and can take immediate action to enhance their performance, leading to better overall outcomes.
By incorporating these recommendations, HR managers can create a performance management system that is trusted, fair, and effective.
Accuracy in evaluations, maintaining integrity and fairness, implementing continuous feedback, involving employees in the process, training managers, and regularly reviewing the system ensure its ongoing relevance and effectiveness.
These 5 key steps help organizations foster a motivated and engaged workforce and create a culture that is conducive to healthy high performance.
Reference: Mayer, R. C., & Davis, J. H. (1999). The effect of the performance appraisal system on trust for management: A field quasi-experiment. Journal of Applied Psychology, 84(1), 123–136.
Want to create a work environment that supports Healthy High Performance in your organization? Click here to learn more about our Enterprise Solutions and talk to our team.
